Checking your browser…

Skip to content
OlioWise

OlioWise / Analyse

Competitions

How often olive oil competitions agree on the same release, which panels award tougher medal tiers, and how awards distribute across the OlioWise archive.

Part 1 · Relative grading

Observed award-tier stringency

When the exact same olive oil release wins at multiple competitions, which panels hand out tougher medals? A positive score (+) means a competition awarded a lower medal tier than peers judging the same oil; a negative score (−) means it awarded a higher tier.

External competitions ranked by observed award-tier stringency among matched winning releases. OlioWise’s internal review scale is excluded.
RankCompetitionAssuranceRelative stringency (95% CI)Matched overlapRecorded medal mixEvidence
1Los Angeles International Olive Oil CompetitionClass B 2026
+0.295+0.125 to +0.466
93 releases 6 peers · 130 total awards
244858
Limited
2SA Olive AwardsClass A 2026
+0.225+0.03 to +0.429
42 releases 6 peers · 197 total awards
229481
Comparable sample
3California State Fair EVOO CompetitionClass A 2026
+0.197+0.081 to +0.319
160 releases 5 peers · 443 total awards
55122266
Comparable sample
4Berlin Global Olive Oil AwardsClass B 2026
+0.091-0.067 to +0.25
62 releases 8 peers · 123 total awards
114666
Comparable sample
5OLIVE JAPAN International Olive Oil CompetitionClass B 2026
+0.065-0.026 to +0.153
199 releases 9 peers · 451 total awards
0242197
Comparable sample
6Australian Golden Olive AwardsClass A 2026
+0.056-0.122 to +0.244
45 releases 3 peers · 83 total awards
63344
Comparable sample
7Australian International Olive AwardsClass A 2026
-0.009-0.153 to +0.132
111 releases 7 peers · 741 total awards
111289341
Comparable sample
8Athena International Olive Oil CompetitionClass A 2026
-0.059-0.255 to +0.124
29 releases 8 peers · 32 total awards
1722
Limited
9London International Olive Oil CompetitionClass A 2021
-0.159-0.311 to -0.013
63 releases 9 peers · 95 total awards
42665
Comparable sample
10New York International Olive Oil CompetitionClass B 2026
-0.215-0.293 to -0.139
298 releases 12 peers · 711 total awards
0227484
Comparable sample
11Japan Olive Oil PrizeClass A 2026
-0.258-0.392 to -0.117
60 releases 8 peers · 111 total awards
01794
Comparable sample
—Olives New Zealand AwardsClass A 2026
—
4 releases 3 peers · 192 total awards
2611452
Insufficient overlap
—Oliveti Northland Olive Oil AwardsClass A 2026
—
2 releases 2 peers · 65 total awards
52733
Insufficient overlap
How stringency & assurance grades are calculated

A competition is ranked once it has at least 10 matched releases across at least 2 external peer competitions. Ranks with overlapping 95% bootstrap intervals are not statistically distinguishable, and differing opponent pools can influence scores. Assurance grades reflect OlioWise’s latest approved rules year: Class A (competition-qualified release), Class B (sensory award evidence), Class C (official result only), and Pending (rules not yet used as verification evidence).

Archive scope and key takeaways

Tracked awards3374
Award-winning oils710
Competitions & scales14
Recorded scores760
OlioWise rated releases16

Key takeaways from the archive

Source records & citation →
Cross-competition overlap

Across 13 external competitions, 11 have enough shared releases to rank by award-tier stringency, and 22 competition pairs share at least 10 identical releases.

Toughest observed medal scale

Los Angeles International Olive Oil Competition currently ranks most stringent (+0.295 across 93 shared releases), awarding a lower broad tier than peers more often when judging the same oil.

Largest head-to-head sample

OLIVE JAPAN International Olive Oil Competition vs New York International Olive Oil Competition (102 shared releases): 61% received the exact same broad medal tier (62/102), and 100% landed within one tier.

Part 2 · Head-to-head explorer

Competition agreement matrix

Select any competition pair below—or pick one of the largest shared samples—to inspect how often two panels awarded the same medal tier to the exact same release.

Top shared samples:

Selected head-to-head comparison

OLIVE JAPAN International Olive Oil Competition vs New York International Olive Oil Competition

102 same-release comparisons across 56 shared oil files. This is observed agreement in OlioWise’s matched-release sample.

Comparable sample

Who graded tougher on shared releases?

OLIVE JAPAN International Olive Oil Competition gave the lower tier more often

OLIVE JAPAN International Olive Oil Competition25lower-tier awards
New York International Olive Oil Competition15lower-tier awards

62 same-tier awards of 102 comparisons

Exact tier match62/102 (61%)
Within 1 medal tier102/102 (100%)
Release years2016, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025
Style consistencyNo releases with styles recorded on both sides

95% Wilson intervals — exact: 51–70%; adjacent: 96–100%.

Inspect tier-by-tier confusion matrix & raw award pairs
Effective-tier confusion matrix; rows are OLIVE JAPAN International Olive Oil Competition, columns are New York International Olive Oil Competition.
Bronze Silver Gold-or-higher
Bronze000
Silver02425
Gold-or-higher01538
Raw award pairs
  • Gold / Gold38
  • Gold / Silver15
  • Silver / Gold25
  • Silver / Silver24

Exact agreement shows how often matched releases received the same broad medal tier. Percentages are withheld below 10 comparisons.

Same-release medal-tier agreement. Rows and columns are award sources.
Row ↓ / Col →OLIVE JAPANAthena IOOCAIOAAGOAONZNYIOOCJOOPLAIOOCLIOOCBerlin GOOASA OliveCalifornia State FairOliveti Northland Olive Oil AwardsOlioWise ReviewInternal scale
OLIVE JAPAN—
Athena IOOC—
AIOA—
AGOA—
ONZ—
NYIOOC—
JOOP—
LAIOOC—
LIOOC—
Berlin GOOA—
SA Olive—
California State Fair—
Oliveti Northland Olive Oil Awards—
OlioWise ReviewInternal scale—

Expanded view

Competition agreement matrix

Exact agreement shows how often matched releases received the same broad medal tier.

Part 3 · Source breakdown

Competition profiles

Medal distributions, recorded numeric score ranges, and original award titles across each tracked source.

451 awards
Bronze
0 (0%)
Silver
242 (55%)
Gold-or-higher
197 (45%)

12 non-tier entries preserved in raw labels below.

Original award labels (5)
  • Best of Country9
  • Gold195
  • Premier2
  • Silver242
  • Toshiya Tada Special Sommelier Award3
32 awards
Bronze
1 (3%)
Silver
7 (23%)
Gold-or-higher
22 (73%)

2 non-tier entries preserved in raw labels below.

Original award labels (5)
  • Best olive oil per country of origin2
  • Bronze1
  • Double Gold6
  • Gold16
  • Silver7

Australian International Olive Awards

Class A148 oils · 2012–2026
741 awards
Numeric scores: 646/74165–96 (median 83)
Bronze
111 (15%)
Silver
289 (39%)
Gold-or-higher
341 (46%)
Original award labels (11)
  • Best2
  • Best in class2
  • Best in Class14
  • Best of Show2
  • Best of State9
  • Bronze111
  • Champion21
  • Gold255
  • Platinum14
  • Reserve Champion22
  • Silver289

Australian Golden Olive Awards

Class A36 oils · 2021–2026
83 awards
Numeric scores: 71/8366–92 (median 86)
Bronze
6 (7%)
Silver
33 (40%)
Gold-or-higher
44 (53%)
Original award labels (6)
  • Best in Class5
  • Best Oil from Heritage Trees5
  • Best Oil in Show3
  • Bronze6
  • Gold31
  • Silver33

Olives New Zealand Awards

Class A77 oils · 2022–2026
192 awards
Bronze
26 (14%)
Silver
114 (59%)
Gold-or-higher
52 (27%)
Original award labels (8)
  • Best in Boutique3
  • Best in Class15
  • Best in Show2
  • Bronze26
  • Gold27
  • Reserve in Boutique2
  • Reserve in Show3
  • Silver114

New York International Olive Oil Competition

Class B214 oils · 2015–2026
711 awards
Bronze
0 (0%)
Silver
227 (32%)
Gold-or-higher
484 (68%)
Original award labels (3)
  • Best in Class5
  • Gold479
  • Silver227

Japan Olive Oil Prize

Class A62 oils · 2020–2026
111 awards
Bronze
0 (0%)
Silver
17 (15%)
Gold-or-higher
94 (85%)
Original award labels (11)
  • 1st Best of Blends1
  • 3rd Best of JOOP 20261
  • 3rd Best of Medium Intensity1
  • Best in Class14
  • Best of Croatia2
  • Best of Greece2
  • Best of Japan1
  • Best of Polyphenols1
  • Best of United States3
  • Gold68
  • Silver17
130 awards
Bronze
24 (19%)
Silver
48 (37%)
Gold-or-higher
58 (45%)
Original award labels (5)
  • Best of Class12
  • Best of Division4
  • Bronze24
  • Gold42
  • Silver48

London International Olive Oil Competition

Class A49 oils · 2020–2026
95 awards
Bronze
4 (4%)
Silver
26 (27%)
Gold-or-higher
65 (68%)
Original award labels (4)
  • Bronze4
  • Gold52
  • Platinum13
  • Silver26

Berlin Global Olive Oil Awards

Class B64 oils · 2020–2026
123 awards
Numeric scores: 36/12383.97–96.88 (median 91.39)
Bronze
11 (9%)
Silver
46 (37%)
Gold-or-higher
66 (54%)
Original award labels (4)
  • Bronze11
  • Gold49
  • Platinum17
  • Silver46

SA Olive Awards

Class A66 oils · 2021–2026
197 awards
Bronze
22 (11%)
Silver
94 (48%)
Gold-or-higher
81 (41%)
Original award labels (3)
  • Bronze22
  • Gold81
  • Silver94

California State Fair EVOO Competition

Class A157 oils · 2022–2026
443 awards
Bronze
55 (12%)
Silver
122 (28%)
Gold-or-higher
266 (60%)
Original award labels (24)
  • Best of California3
  • Best of California EVOO Blend Delicate1
  • Best of California EVOO Blend Medium2
  • Best of California EVOO Blend Robust2
  • Best of California EVOO by a Artisan Producer3
  • Best of California EVOO by a Large Producer3
  • Best of California EVOO by a Micro Producer3
  • Best of California EVOO Monovarietal Delicate2
  • Best of California EVOO Monovarietal Medium2
  • Best of California EVOO Monovarietal Robust2
  • Best of California EVOO Single Variety Delicate1
  • Best of California EVOO Single Variety Medium1
  • Best of California EVOO Single Variety Robust1
  • Best of California Large Producer1
  • Best of California Microproducer1
  • Best of Class44
  • Best of Show Blend Extra Virgin Olive Oil1
  • Best of Show Extra Virgin Olive Oil2
  • Best of Show Monovarietal Extra Virgin Olive Oil1
  • Best of Show Olive Oil2
  • Bronze55
  • Double Gold8
  • Gold180
  • Silver122

Oliveti Northland Olive Oil Awards

Class A17 oils · 2015–2026
65 awards
Numeric scores: 7/6579.5–92 (median 89.5)
Bronze
5 (8%)
Silver
27 (42%)
Gold-or-higher
33 (51%)
Original award labels (5)
  • Best in Class11
  • Best in Show3
  • Bronze5
  • Gold19
  • Silver27

OlioWise Review

Internal review scale14 oils
16 awards
Bronze
5 (31%)
Silver
7 (44%)
Gold-or-higher
4 (25%)
Original award labels (3)
  • Bronze5
  • Gold-or-higher4
  • Silver7

Part 4 · Reference & provenance

Methodology, grouping & citation

How awards are grouped

Cross-competition comparisons use three broad tiers: Bronze, Silver, and Gold-or-higher. Higher honours retain their original labels on oil pages.

Bronze Bronze
Silver Silver
Gold Gold-or-higher
Platinum Gold-or-higher
Double Gold Gold-or-higher
Best / Champion / Reserve / Class / Show honours Gold-or-higher

Recorded numeric scores

Numeric scores are summarised only within their original competition. Different judging panels are not placed on a shared numeric scale, and generated proxy scores are never used.

AIOA

646/741 scored

Range 65–96 · median 83

AGOA

71/83 scored

Range 66–92 · median 86

Berlin GOOA

36/123 scored

Range 83.97–96.88 · median 91.39

Oliveti Northland Olive Oil Awards

7/65 scored

Range 79.5–92 · median 89.5

Full methodology & statistical assumptions

Release identity: Same oil content file and release year. Multiple awards from one source on the same release reduce to the strongest effective tier.

Uncertainty & thresholds: Rates show raw counts. A 95% Wilson interval is calculated for samples of at least 10; smaller samples are labelled anecdotal.

Category differences: Judging panels, style classes, volume classes, and entrant pools differ. Missing style data is treated as not comparable rather than a mismatch.

Stringency model: Mean matched-release gap between peer award tiers and this competition’s award tier. Positive values mean this competition awarded a lower broad tier than its matched peers. Requires at least 10 matched releases across 2 external peers.

Assurance class: Latest approved competition evidence class from the assurance registry; Pending if no approved year is recorded.

Archive limits: Winner archive, not a record of all competition entrants. These statistics cannot determine selectivity, difficulty, prestige, or a universal award conversion.

Cite this analysis

Snapshot 1046f689e1d8 · Method v2

OlioWise. “Competition Award Agreement.” Calculated 18 Nov 2026. Method v2. Input snapshot 1046f689e1d8. https://www.oliowise.com/stats/competitions/.

This report updates as catalog records expand. Underlying observations link to OlioWise’s oil pages (release year and competition year can differ). To report a correction, contact OlioWise with the oil, release year, competition, and supporting source.

Browse all source observations (3390)